Phillip October 4, 2023 No Comments

NURS FPX 6109 Assessment 3 Educational Technologies Comparison

NURS FPX 6109 Assessment 3 Educational Technologies Comparison

Student Name

Capella University

NURS-FPX 6109 Integrating Technology into Nursing Education

Prof. Name

Date

Part 1

The integration of technology into the field of education has brought about a shift in the way we learn and teach. One notable innovation is the introduction of Learning Management Systems (LMSs) which have greatly impacted nursing education. These platforms have completely transformed how nursing students receive and manage their education offering an interactive learning experience. In this assessment, we will analyze two used LMSs, Canvas and Blackboard. To evaluate their features, benefits, and capabilities. Our ultimate goal is to determine which system would be most suitable, for teaching and learning scenarios in nursing education.

Description of Technology

In the field of nursing education an LMS refers to a software application that educators use to create, manage and deliver courses and programs to students. It plays a role in handling records, administration courses, tracking student progress, and sharing learning materials. These systems also often include features for collaboration. Allow educators to develop and integrate course materials, define learning objectives, align content with assessment, and monitor student advancement (Hermosisima et al., 2023).

The two specific LMS platforms I will be examining are Canvas and Blackboard. Canvas is an LMS that supports teaching and learning through its reliable, customizable, adaptable and mobile-friendly platform. It’s designed to allow institutions to build a digital learning environment that meets the unique challenges and requirements faced in their context. Whereas, Blackboard is an established player in the LMS market and offers a suite of education tools for course management, a virtual learning environment, and an array of services like gradebooks, mass notification services, and software for plagiarism detection (Liu & Yu, 2022).

Comparison of Features, Benefits, and Capabilities

 

Feature, Capability, and Benefit

Version 1 (CANVAS): 

Version 2 (BLACKBOARD): 

User Interface Canvas is known for its clean, intuitive, and modern user interface (UI). The dashboard and course navigation are highly praised for being user-friendly and straightforward, even for those with minimal tech experience. Blackboard’s UI is robust and functional but has a steeper learning curve. It may require more familiarization time for those new to the system.
Customization Canvas offers a high level of customization, allowing educators to modify course designs according to their preferences or institutional needs. Also, provides learners the flexibility to adjust their learning environments. Blackboard allows for customization, but it’s not as flexible or comprehensive as Canvas. The ability to personalize is present, but the options might be more limited.
Mobile Access Canvas has a well-designed mobile app that is comprehensive and mirrors much of the web platform’s functionality. This gives students and teachers a seamless experience across devices. Blackboard offers a functional mobile app, but it has fewer features compared to its web interface or the Canvas mobile app.
Integration with Third-Party Apps Canvas excels with extensive integration options with third-party apps, enriching its functionality and providing opportunities for a more tailored learning environment. Blackboard also offers integration with third-party apps, the number of integrations is not as extensive as Canvas.
Learning Analytics Canvas provides comprehensive analytics tools that allow educators to track student progress and engagement. This feature can inform instructional decisions and help identify students who might be struggling. Blackboard also offers analytics capabilities, but they might not be as extensive or user-friendly as Canvas’s analytics tools.

NURS FPX 6109 Assessment 3 Educational Technologies Comparison

Part 2

Assumptions

The comparison between Canvas and Blackboard is undertaken based on a few assumptions. It is presumed that all users have the necessary hardware and stable internet access to use these online platforms. It is also assumed that users have an understanding of computers and can effectively navigate and use these platforms. Both Canvas and Blackboard offer functionalities such as learning management systems (LMSs). However, they differ in terms of the user interface, customization options, mobile accessibility, integration with third-party apps, and the ability to analyze learning data. By examining these features, advantages, and capabilities this comparison provides a basis for making decisions about which technology would be most suitable for educational needs, in a nursing education setting (Aithal & Aithal 2023; Mahmoud & Withorn, 2023)

Benefits and Limitations of Comparing Similar Educational Technologies

Comparing Canvas and Blackboard provides insights for decision making. By examining their features, benefits, and capabilities side by side one can easily understand the options. Make a choice. Our analysis revealed that Canvas surpasses Blackboard in terms of user interface and integration with third-party tools. These specific findings are particularly useful for decision-makers who prioritize user experience and technological adaptability (Hermosisima et al., 2023). However, it’s important to acknowledge that this comparative approach has its limitations. While it allows us to evaluate features and functionalities it may not fully capture the user experiences offered by each platform. Some users might find the Canvas interface more intuitive while others might prefer Blackboard due to their familiarity with the platform. Therefore, it’s essential to consider that this comparison may not accurately represent the experiences of all users (Liu & Yu 2022).

We must not overlook the aspects when comparing Canvas and Blackboard. Both platforms have pricing models that can significantly impact the decision, especially for institutions operating on a tight budget. Moreover, it’s important to note that different institutions have specific requirements. This comparison doesn’t consider the specialized features that an institution might need (Mahmoud & Withorn, 2023). In conclusion, although this comparison is a starting point it’s crucial to recognize its limitations. Decision makers should augment this comparison, with research that caters to their institution’s needs, user preferences, and financial capabilities, in order to make the most well-informed decision.

Analysis

Suitable Teaching and Learning Situations

When determining the situations, for using Canvas and Blackboard in teaching and learning it’s important to consider their unique characteristics. Canvas stands out with its user-modern interface, customizable options, mobile app compatibility, integration with third-party apps, and robust analytics tools. It excels in dynamic learning environments that embrace technology, where users expect navigation, flexibility, and seamless integration with digital tools. Canvas proves advantageous when educators want to experiment with teaching approaches that utilize analytics to track student progress and adapt their teaching methods based on that data (Biliuk et al., 2023).

NURS FPX 6109 Assessment 3 Educational Technologies Comparison

On the other hand, Blackboard has its strengths rooted in its reputation and comprehensive feature set. While it may not have the interface or extensive third-party integration as Canvas does, it remains a reliable choice for educational institutions that value stability and functionality over cutting-edge design or extensive customization. Blackboard suits teaching environments where users are more comfortable, with a familiar platform and may not necessarily require extensive customization or third-party integrations (Biliuk et al., 2023; Hermosisima et al., 2023). Ultimately the decision between Canvas and Blackboard relies on the needs and context of the teaching and learning scenarios. If you are in a dynamic and data-driven environment Canvas would be a great fit. However, if you prefer a stable approach Blackboard would be a suitable choice. So it’s crucial for decision-makers to carefully consider their circumstances and requirements before making a choice, for their teaching and learning needs.

Incorporating Technology into a Specific Program

Incorporating a Learning Management System (LMS) such as Canvas or Blackboard into a nursing education program has the potential to revolutionize the teaching and learning process offering advantages that contribute to results. However, the approach to integrating these platforms may vary depending on their characteristics. Canvas for instance with its user interface and wide range of customization options can function as a hub for delivering various educational resources, like lectures, reading materials, assignments, and quizzes. Its comprehensive mobile app and third-party integration capabilities would allow for seamless access to study materials and resources on mobile devices, as well as the use of other useful educational apps alongside Canvas (Biliuk et al., 2023). Its comprehensive analytics tools would provide educators with valuable insights into student engagement and progress, enabling them to adjust their teaching strategies as necessary for optimal learning outcomes (Wittenberg et al., 2021).

NURS FPX 6109 Assessment 3 Educational Technologies Comparison

Incorporating Blackboard into a nursing education program, while also resulting in a centralized platform for education content, might focus more on leveraging its robustness and comprehensive feature set. While the user interface might take some getting used to, the platform’s reliability and comprehensive functionalities would provide a stable online learning environment. Blackboard’s moderate analytics capabilities could still offer useful insights for educators to track student progress, though perhaps not as extensively as Canvas (Biliuk et al., 2023)/

Conclusion

The comparison and analysis of Canvas and Blackboard highlight the importance of context when selecting educational technologies. Both LMSs offer robust features that can significantly enhance teaching, learning, and assessment in a nursing education program. However, their effectiveness is contingent on how well they align with specific institutional needs, resources, and objectives. For instance, while Canvas might be ideal for institutions valuing an intuitive user experience and extensive third-party integrations, Blackboard may be preferable for those valuing stability and a comprehensive feature set. Ultimately, the choice between these LMSs should reflect a comprehensive understanding of the technology’s capabilities and the specific needs of the nursing education program. By doing so, educators can ensure that they maximize the potential benefits of these technologies, paving the way for improved learning outcomes and a more engaging educational experience.

References

Aithal, P. S., & Aithal, S. (2023, May 20). Stakeholders’ analysis of the effect of ubiquitous education technologies on higher education. Social Science Research Network. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4453569 

Biliuk, O., Stepanenko, O., & Kyrychenko, V. (2023). Modern tools for distance education: Information and analytical prospectus. Futurity Education, 3(2), 233–247. https://doi.org/10.57125/FED.2023.06.25.15 

Mahmoud, S., & Withorn, T. (2023). Faculty-librarian collaboration to enhance information literacy skills in an online nursing course. Nursing Education Perspectives. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.NEP.0000000000001145 

NURS FPX 6109 Assessment 3 Educational Technologies Comparison

Hermosisima, M. C. R., Mobo, F. D., & Cutillas, A. L. (2023). Enhanced learning continuity framework using online teaching as alternative delivery modality. International Journal of Multidisciplinary: Applied Business and Education Research, 4(5), 1521–1534. https://doi.org/10.11594/ijmaber.04.05.14 

Liu, M., & Yu, D. (2022). Towards intelligent E-learning systems. Education and Information Technologies. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10639-022-11479-6 

Wittenberg, E., Johnson, R. R., & Tayyeb, A. R. (2021). Utilizing an online communication module with baccalaureate nursing students to teach leadership in team meetings. Nursing Education Perspectives, Publish Ahead of Print. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.nep.0000000000000914